data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/4da68/4da681016abcc7eb4c1ced493c3eb337887537e6" alt="Stuttering fefe dobson"
The video than flashes back to Dobson being in a car that crashed causing her to have amnesia. She then proceeds to run out of the hotel room and takes off the jacket, when the French cowboy grabs her and yells at her for 'bringing a lot of business but not paying' and she starts to remember a party that she went to and cheated on her boyfriend. Once she gets there she puts on a leather jacket (owned by the man's girlfriend), then the girlfriend comes into the room and the music stops while she says, "Who the hell are you!" and Dobson retorts, "Who the hell are you?" Just then the man gets out of the shower and Dobson realizes that she does not know him. As she walks to his hotel room she sings. The video begins with Dobson questioning a hotel manager (a French cowboy) about her boyfriend and she thinks he is covering for him, she then sees a man she believes is him. In the United States, the song peaked at number 65 on the Hot 100 Airplay chart and at number 39 on the Pop Songs chart, marking her first entry on the latter since " Everything" in 2004. It also is her highest-charting single from Joy, outpeaking the prior single, " Ghost", which peaked at number 14. It ultimately peaked at number 10 on the chart, making it Dobson's first top ten on the new chart format and first top ten since 2004. "Stuttering" has charted on the Canadian Hot 100, debuting at number 78 on the issue dated November 6, 2010.
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/9bba0/9bba03d23789ec326c4ba664d1660012eaf77778" alt="stuttering fefe dobson stuttering fefe dobson"
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/d94fd/d94fd2b5fe778cc43e273e80e834c6465af4f8ac" alt="stuttering fefe dobson stuttering fefe dobson"
Complimenting Dobson's vocal performance, Sputnikmusic wrote, "she belts out impressively high and quick notes during the chorus with no real effort at all, because the girl can sing." Chart performance AllMusic's Matthew Chisling wrote that "Stuttering" "proves on top of the pop market, with some immaculate writing and production". "Stuttering" has garnered generally positive reviews from music critics.
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/4da68/4da681016abcc7eb4c1ced493c3eb337887537e6" alt="Stuttering fefe dobson"